2025 Property Insurance Risk Outlook

The year ahead could be pivotal for property insurers. After 2024’s mix of climate uncertainties, shifting regulatory landscapes, and head-spinning technological advances, savvier carriers are poised to recalibrate their strategies for growth and resilience, come what may. Trends likely to shape 2025 encompass not only the challenges the industry faces, but also significant opportunities for insurers to innovate, differentiate, and lead. Here’s a look at what’s coming—and how insurers can get ahead. 

Hard Market or Soft? It Depends on Your Mix of Business

Both commercial and personal lines insurers have navigated hard market conditions throughout 2024. But while Swiss Re sees conditions beginning to ease in 2025, the reality will be geographically nuanced and, as the global insurance giant points out, shaped by an incoming U.S. administration whose policies may slow disinflation or even lead to weakened demand and slacking profitability in exposed lines. 

Localized Challenges, Hyper-Localized Solutions

For carriers operating in high-risk states—such as Florida, Louisiana, and increasingly Texas—where competitors continue to take rate and cut coverage, the market is likely to seem as hard as ever. Conversely, carriers that implemented rate adjustments a few years ago and achieved or maintained profitability in 2024 are likely to view conditions as softening. 
In the year ahead, property insurers will need to refine their strategies as market conditions warrant. For example, states with high hail risk and areas facing significant reinsurance challenges may continue to see counterparts pulling back. Meanwhile, regions spared from catastrophic losses in recent years could see significant growth. The key to navigating these bifurcated conditions lies in hyper-localized property intelligence that allows carriers to tailor coverage and pricing and (selectively) expand their books while remaining vigilant about evolving risks.

Climate Risks Aren’t Going Away–But They Will Bring Opportunity

An unexpected lull in major weather-related catastrophes (CATs) in 2024 may also give carriers a false sense of the risk to their books in 2025. Yes, total economic losses from natural catastrophes ran roughly 10% lower than the 10-year average for the first three quarters of the year, according to Gallagher Re. But pure luck played a sizable role. Just look at Hurricane Milton, which caused as much as $34 billion in damage. Had vanishingly minute changes to its trajectory put its landfall just 10 miles north, losses could have been $50 billion or more.

Rising Temperatures, Scorching Stakes

As reported by the New York Times, 2024 was also the first full year to exceed temperature limits set by the Paris Climate Agreement. In that 2015 treaty, 195 nations pledged to ensure that the world’s average surface temperature doesn’t rise any higher than 1.5°C by the year 2100. Instead of 85 years, we breached that threshold in less than 10. Rising temperatures increase the frequency and severity of catastrophic weather events everywhere. But the truth is readily available technologies exist today that can be used to make more properties insurable and mitigate the loss of coverage by so many property owners in California, Florida, Texas, and elsewhere. Look for a growing number of insurers to embrace AI-enhanced property intelligence that enables them to drive growth where others fear to tread by selecting the best risks and avoiding the properties most likely to account for the majority of CAT losses.  

Regulatory Pressures: From Compliance to Collaboration

The growing threat from hail, wildfire, record-breaking temperatures, and other climate-related dangers are drawing the attention of regulators, and 2025 will see a heightened focus on how carriers assess and manage property risk. California’s “game-changing” move to require insurers to make coverage commitments for underserved areas in order to use catastrophe modeling for ratemaking is just one example. But instead of merely reacting to mandates, leading insurers are embracing a collaborative approach. 

Shifting the Narrative

Combined with climate-related risk, the impact of technologies used to assess that risk will also come under increased scrutiny. In 2025, property insurers will face increasing calls for standardized guidelines around the use of data, AI, aerial imagery, and more. Look for a growing number of carriers to swap mere compliance for collaboration, working together with regulators to help ensure they can deliver the coverage consumers and businesses need while safeguarding their own competitive advantage. 

States like Louisiana, for example, are already experimenting with regulatory frameworks designed to support both consumers and carriers in high-risk areas. Carriers who invest in ethical AI practices, strong model governance safeguards, and transparent methodologies will not only minimize regulatory headaches but also foster trust with stakeholders. Look for many to prioritize property intelligence solutions approved for use in 40 or more states for rating and underwriting. 

Interior Intel: Carriers Take Steps to Close $2 Billion Gap 

Accurate property data has always been a cornerstone of effective underwriting, yet one critical blind spot remains: interior living area data. Today, errors in this seemingly basic metric result in billions of dollars in lost premiums for carriers and heightened exposure to underinsured risks for policyholders. 

No Room for Inaccuracy

With construction costs up more than 30% since 2020, and with 64% of U.S. homes underinsured, precise living area assessments are more vital than ever. Over the next 12 months, tech-forward insurers will embrace modern AI-powered solutions that provide accurate, multi-source data—including public records, contractor estimates, and even interior inspection datasets—to fix these discrepancies. By correcting errors, insurers can not only recover lost premium revenue—estimated at over $2 billion annually—but also ensure adequate coverage levels while reducing financial risk for policyholders.

2025 will also see next-gen technologies and data sources provide more consistent and objective evaluations of interior quality grade. This will further reduce reliance on outdated or self-reported information and on-site inspections. In addition to improved underwriting accuracy, carriers will be able to better align premiums with true risk, minimize surprises during claims, and build trust with policyholders.

Customer & Agent Experience: The Ultimate Differentiator 

In an industry often criticized for complexity and opacity, customer and agent experience is emerging as a critical battleground. The trends outlined above—whether it’s leveraging AI for risk assessment or collaborating with regulators—ultimately converge on a singular goal: delivering better outcomes for policyholders. 

Speed, Agility & Transparency Gain Traction

The truth is modern consumers demand speed and clarity from every organization with which they do business. And the property insurance sector is no different. Carriers that can process applications faster, provide competitive pricing on truly tailored coverage, and offer greater transparency will win. AI-powered tools play a pivotal role here, enabling insurers to make real-time risk decisions that are precise, personalized, and transparent. These tools and transparency also serve to improve the relationship between underwriters and agents, especially in a highly dynamic environment where carriers are quickly changing their guidelines across multiple dimensions. This kind of operational agility allows carriers to effectively navigate market fluctuations—hard, soft, or otherwise. 

Look Alive in ’25: Turning Trends into Triumphs

As the property insurance industry enters 2025, the stakes for “the business of risk” have never been higher. Those able to lean into innovation—by leveraging AI, refining data accuracy, and collaborating with regulators—will be best positioned to lead the market. The ability to pivot quickly to meet evolving policyholder needs will separate leaders and laggards in 2025—and beyond.

---

To learn more about how AI-powered, multi-source property intelligence can help property insurers select better risks, reduce expenses, and enhance the agent and customer experience, request a demo today.